Delivery Tech WatchArticles

Automating Last Mile Delivery #5

Welcome back to the fifth edition of my newsletter tracking robot and drone delivery operations in the US! I'll go into how delivery robots and the sidewalks they roll on shape each other, the continuation of the campus robot swapping, a two-company pilot, how loud different delivery drones are, and more.

Featured: Delivery Robots and the Sidewalks

One of the most persistent anti-robot arguments is that they get in the way, blocking sidewalks and adding traffic to pedestrian infrastructure that cities already struggle to maintain. Last September, a viral video showed a Serve Robotics repeatedly swerve into and then abruptly come to a stop in the path of Mark Chaney, a therapist and advocate with cerebral palsy, making physical contact with him. He said that if he had been on crutches instead of his scooter, he would have fallen, which could take him weeks to recover. Serve acknowledged that predicting a person's movements in real time is challenging and the robot stopping in his way was due to it determining that the safest course of action was to come to a complete stop.

Serve also said it was "fast-tracking" the launch of an Accessibility Council, yet nearly a year later there is no public evidence of its formation. Chaney had volunteered to sit on it and sent a follow-up email with suggestions, but still had not heard back two weeks later. What Serve does have is a public accessibility commitments page promising "community co-design" with disability advocates, alongside features such as audible cues developed with input from the blind community to help people track a robot's position.

Similar complaints led Toronto to ban delivery robots from sidewalks back in 2021 after disability advocates raised safety concerns, and a petition in Chicago gathered thousands of signatures asking the city to pause robot deliveries and require more safety data.

At the same time, the industry has started turning its dependence on sidewalks into something pedestrians can benefit from. In April, Coco Robotics partnered with BlindSquare, the most widely used accessible GPS app for blind and partially-sighted users. As Coco's robots log sidewalk hazards, that data flows to BlindSquare, with a two-way loop so users can mark obstacles as cleared and update Coco's maps in return. The project began in Helsinki under a European Union grant and is now live in Los Angeles, Chicago, Miami, and Jersey City. Robot.com, meanwhile, is mapping sidewalk obstructions in Washington, DC and Arlington, Virginia, and already last year it's captured ~35,000 data points tracking issues by type and severity. According to Next City, even the idea of mounting air quality measuring devices to the robots has been suggested since they'd be traveling where people are and closer to ground level.

The money is starting to follow the data, if slowly. When Coco found that missing curb ramps on Abbot Kinney Boulevard in Venice turned certain blocks into islands for wheelchair users and its own robots, it used its routing data to identify where ramps would unlock the whole area, then worked through the local council office to get 3 of them added. And West Hollywood, the site of the Chaney collision, may be running the first program of its kind: operators Serve and Coco now pay annual fees, face penalties for ADA and geofencing violations, and share advertising revenue at $4 per robot per day, with everything flowing into a dedicated fund for accessibility improvements estimated at $40,000 to $80,000 per year.

These robots need exactly the same infrastructure that pedestrians do, so the industry has a direct commercial interest in the accessibility upgrades disability advocates have been requesting. And the obstacle detection the robots must do produces citywide sidewalk-condition data that most cities don't collect themselves. But between goodwill programs and viral collisions, word about incidents travel much faster than curb ramps get built. Whether companies can address problems quickly enough and make their technology more amenable to sharing spaces with humans remains to be seen.

Top Picks

New brand of delivery robots takes over George Mason University's Fairfax campus (FFXnow)

Back in the second edition, I included a social media post from student who had spotted Avride robots mapping George Mason University's campus in July. Now, Avride has gone live on the first day of the fall semester, replacing the Starship robots that had served the campus since 2019, with ordering through Grubhub. Georgia Tech also officially named Avride as its new provider for the fall with ordering through Grubhub after pausing robot delivery services over the summer. And according to James Madison University's student paper, that university has reportedly made the same switch, which would fit Avride's takeover of the space Starship is leaving behind.

Hoboken approves robot delivery pilot program (Hoboken Girl)

The New Jersey city of Hoboken has approved a two-operator pilot program for Coco Robotics and Avride. They have been each running 10 robots in the city's First Ward area for 12 months since September 3, serving orders through DoorDash, Uber Eats, or Grubhub. The program is intended to test how the robots can support local businesses and ensure pedestrian safety and accessibility while completing deliveries to determine if they would "be a positive addition to [the] city".

On August 12, the city passed an ordinance amending Chapter 190 to create Article XXXIX, "Autonomous or Remotely Operated Devices", which sets an application fee, annual permit fee, and a discretionary administrative fee. Through the fees, the city will receive $5,800 in revenue over the course of the pilot. It also regulates both delivery robots and drones and is very specific about accessibility and data, more so than San José's draft. For example, it requires 4 feet minimum of passable sidewalk clearance at all times, tactile Braille signage with a monitored contact number, and a data-sharing plan in Mobility Data Specification format.

Transportation Secretary announces major expansion of FAA BEYOND program (US DOT)

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) is doubling its BEYOND drone program, adding up to 8 more lead participants focused on Beyond Visual Line of Sight (BVLOS) operations. The key capability for scalable drone delivery is being able to fly drones farther than an observer on the ground can see them; otherwise, operations are significantly more constrained. Phase 1 logged over 70,000 flights, including more than 48,000 BVLOS operations, which provides the FAA's stated basis for the still-pending Part 108 rule that would make such operations routine rather than exemption-based.

Delivery drones are loud. It could decide who wins the drone wars (Axios)

FAA testing measured drone noise at 50 feet: Zipline at 79 decibels, Wing at 84, and Amazon's MK30 at 88. For reference, a vacuum cleaner is 80 dB and a leaf blower 90 dB. The volume of deliveries keeps climbing regardless: Fortune reports Wing and Walmart are approaching 2 million cumulative deliveries, roughly double the figure from just 3 months ago. Noise was one of the main objections raised by St. Louis-area residents opposing Wing's Walmart drone hubs covered last edition, so it will be interesting to see whether decibels end up mattering as much as delivery counts when cities decide who gets to fly.

That's all from me — thanks for reading! Stay awesome and see you next time!

This newsletter is also published on my Medium and Substack accounts. Subscribe there to get the latest edition in right your inbox.